Stainless Steel Vs Mild Steel: Which Material Reigns Supreme?

Understanding Stainless Steel vs. Mild Steel is vital, especially for those in sectors like construction, automobile, and others.

This blog delves into the composition, properties, manufacturing, costs, applications, safety, maintenance, and environmental impact of both materials.

Understanding The Basics

What is Stainless Steel?

Stainless Steel Vs. Mild Steel

Composition:

Chromium presence uniquely differentiates stainless steel. Chromium, a hard, shiny metal, adds up to 10.5% to 30% of the alloy composition. Nickel, molybdenum, and nitrogen also enhance stainless steel.

Chromium impregnation strengthens stainless steel’s defense against rusting. Steel’s characteristics are heightened via thermal methodologies. Austenitic, duplex, and others are examples of the broad stainless steel range.

Each has unique attributes. Highly formable and corrosion-resistant, it fits diverse applications.

Your car’s exhaust system may contain ferritic stainless steel, a magnetizable type with 12% chromium and low carbon content.

Types of Stainless Steel:

  • Austenitic: A non-magnetic version, with specified chromium and nickel amounts, works well in food preparation and chemical operations.
  • Ferritic: This magnetic type, with 11-17% chromium, is predominantly selected for automobile uses.
  • Martensitic: With 11-17% chromium and under 0.4% nickel, it’s employed in making tools and utensils.
  • Duplex: An amalgamation of austenitic and ferritic types, offering doubled strength and exceptional corrosion resistance.
  • Precipitation-Hardening: Known for its enhanced strength and corrosion resistance, it’s widely used in aerospace applications.
Criteria Stainless Steel Austenitic Stainless Steel Ferritic Stainless Steel Martensitic Stainless Steel Duplex Stainless Steel Precipitation-Hardening Stainless Steel
Main Ingredient Iron Iron Iron Iron Iron Iron
Chromium Content (%) 10.5-30 16-26 11-17 11-17 Variable (mix of austenitic and ferritic) Variable
Nickel Content (%) Variable Up to 35 Low/None <0.4 Variable (mix of austenitic and ferritic) Variable
Corrosion Resistance Yes High Medium Medium High High
Magnetic Depends on type No Yes Yes Depends on composition Depends on the heat treatment
Typical Use Varied Kitchen equipment, chemical processing Automotive applications Tools, cutlery High-strength applications Aerospace applications
Key Features Chromium-rich, shiny, rust-resistant Non-magnetic, highly formable Magnetic, low-carbon content Less nickel content Excellent corrosion resistance, high strength Superior strength, corrosion resistance

The table on Stainless Steel

What is Mild Steel?

Pic 2

Mild steel contains only 0.3% carbon. Easily weldable, mild steel forms the backbone of many structures.

Composition:

Mild steel contains 0.05%-0.25% carbon, making it malleable and ductile. It also contains a moderate amount of manganese. Contrarily, mild steel does not possess additional alloying constituents, resulting in diminished resistance to thermal and corrosive challenges.

Four primary types of mild steel exist. Each differs in terms of carbon content, hardness, and strength.

For instance, low-carbon mild steel, with 0.05%-0.3% carbon, serves as a perfect material for car body panels due to its formability.

Types of Mild Steel:

  • Low Carbon: Car parts manufacturing leans on the internal carbon concentration of the material.
  • Medium Carbon: Contains 0.3%-0.6% carbon – Used for large structures and forged parts.
  • High Carbon: Contains 0.6%-1% carbon – Chosen for springs and high-strength wires.
  • Very High Carbon: Contains 1%-2% carbon – Utilized for knives and axles.

Properties Of Stainless Steel And Mild Steel

Mechanical Properties

Strength

Stainless steel, known for robustness, withstands pressure up to 515 Megapascals (MPa). In contrast, mild steel’s strength ranges between 370-500 MPa.

Stainless steel, recognized for its high yield strength, is the material of choice for engineers during the construction of buildings.

Stainless steel’s superior stress endurance, in comparison to mild steel, is advantageous in rigorous applications.

Ductility

Stainless steel and mild steel show good ductility – the ability to deform without breaking. Yet, mild steel outperforms with a 40% elongation rate.

A 30% rate of elongation characterizes stainless steel. When high deformation is demanded, mild steel steps up as the ideal pick.

Hardness

Hardness measures resistance to deformation. Stainless steel rates 95 on the Rockwell B scale, while mild steel scores 70.

Thus, stainless steel resists deformation better. Industries necessitating hard materials frequently opt for stainless steel.

Toughness

Toughness varies between the two. Stainless steel absorbs up to 200 Joules (J), while mild steel can absorb up to 27 J. Consequently, stainless steel provides superior toughness.

Magnetization

Stainless steel is not magnetic. Mild steel, however, does show strong magnetism. Industries requiring magnetic materials choose mild steel.

Weldability

Both materials offer good weldability. But, mild steel, with lower carbon content, welds easier. Welders favor mild steel for complex, high-precision welding tasks.

Aesthetics

Stainless steel wins in aesthetics. Its shiny, modern look appeals to architects and designers. The visual allure of stainless steel outshines the rather lackluster presentation of mild steel.

Chemical Properties

Corrosion Resistance

The chromium oxide layer fortifies stainless steel against rust. Mild steel lacks this protection, hence corrodes quicker. In corrosion-prone environments, stainless steel is the go-to choice.

Heat Resistance

Stainless steel better withstand heat compared to mild steel. It can withstand temperatures up to 870°C, while mild steel handles up to 800°C. For high-temperature applications, stainless steel proves superior.

Physical Properties

Magnetism

In contrast to mild steel, stainless steel lacks magnetic properties, as stated previously. This property determines their use in different applications.

Appearance

Stainless steel’s glossy finish provides a modern, clean look. The surface of mild steel exhibits a flat, unimpressive visual attribute, devoid of luster.

Density

With a density measurement of 8g/cm3, stainless steel is somewhat denser than mild steel at 7.85g/cm3. For building featherweight structures, mild steel frequently gets the nod.

Properties Stainless Steel Mild Steel
Strength (MPa) Up to 515 370-500
Ductility (% Elongation) 30% 40%
Hardness (Rockwell B Scale) 95 70
Toughness (Joules) Up to 200 Up to 27
Magnetization Not Magnetic Magnetic
Weldability Good, but more difficult Easier, favored for precision welding
Aesthetics Shiny, Modern Look Dull Appearance
Corrosion Resistance High (due to chromium oxide layer) Low
Heat Resistance (°C) Up to 870 Up to 800
Density (g/cm³) 8 7.85

The table on Stainless and Mild Steel

Manufacturing Process

How Stainless Steel Is Made?

  • Iron Ore Extraction: Mining companies gather iron ore, the primary component in stainless steel. For comparison, mild steel uses almost 98% iron ore.
  • Chromium Inclusion: Stainless steel production demands a chromium content of roughly 10%. Rust-fighting capability in mild steel is reduced due to the chromium void.
  • Nickel Addition: Nickel strengthens the material and amplifies its rust-prevention abilities. Unlike mild steel, stainless steel may hold up to 8% nickel.
  • Carbon Reduction: Stainless steel carries less than 0.03% carbon. Mild steel accommodates significant carbon content within this specified range.
  • Forming And Shaping: Factories shape and form stainless steel into sheets, bars, and tubes. Despite its versatility, mild steel falls short of matching aesthetic finesse.
  • Heat Treatment: Stainless steel strength gets a boost via thermal processing. Although mild steel also undergoes a similar thermal process, the resultant characteristics differ.
  • Surface Finish: The final stage involves polishing for a clean, shiny finish. Mild steel doesn’t shine but can be painted for a pleasing look.

How Mild Steel Is Made?

  • Iron Ore Mining: Like stainless steel, mild steel begins with iron ore. However, mild steel production needs a higher iron ore concentration, up to 98%.
  • Carbon Addition: Carbon, making up to 0.25% of mild steel, is added for hardness. In contrast, stainless steel contains less than 0.03% carbon.
  • Manganese Inclusion: Add a little manganese to boost the steel’s workability. Stainless steel usually does not contain manganese.
  • Forming And Shaping: The malleability of mild steel allows for easy shaping into diverse formations. Apart from flexibility, stainless steel also excels in applications requiring a visual appeal.
  • Heat Treatment: Mild steel undergoes heat treatment to improve toughness. Unlike stainless steel, mild steel doesn’t provide anti-corrosion advantages post-process.
  • Surface Finish: Paint or coat mild steel to prevent rust. Chromium-rich stainless steel naturally fights corrosion sans additional coatings.
  • Recycling: Mild steel stands as the material most frequently recycled. Despite the recyclability of stainless steel, the recycling frequency of mild steel surpasses it.
  • Durability Check: Despite less corrosion resistance, mild steel offers high durability. The advantageous combination of longevity and rust resistance is a hallmark of stainless steel.

Cost Comparison Of Stainless Steel Vs. Mild Steel

Initial Cost

For metal projects, material choice matters. Stainless steel, in general, costs more.

The alloy blend of chromium and nickel confers marked resistance against rust. Stainless steel costs around $1.50 to $3 per pound.

Mild steel costs less. Made from iron and carbon, it lacks the alloys found in stainless steel. That means it’s less resistant to rust. But it’s cheaper, too. Usually, mild steel costs between $0.50 to $0.75 per pound.

For big projects, the price difference adds up. Building a structure with 1000 pounds of stainless steel could cost up to $3000. With mild steel, the same project might only cost $750.

Life-Cycle Cost

When it comes to life-cycle costs, stainless steel shows value. Its corrosion resistance means less maintenance. It also has a longer lifespan. Over 30 years, maintenance costs for stainless steel could be 5% of the initial cost. That’s $150 for every $3000 spent.

Mild steel, though cheaper, needs more upkeep. Regular painting and sealing can cost 20% of the initial cost over 30 years. That’s $150 for a $750 project.

Furthermore, stainless steel withstands harsh conditions. In extreme temperatures, it retains its strength. That means fewer replacements, lowering life-cycle costs.

Resale Value

Finally, consider resale value. Stainless steel holds value well. Even after years, used stainless steel can fetch 60% of its original cost. That’s $1800 for a $3000 project.

Mild steel depreciates faster. After years of use, it might only fetch 30% of its original cost. That’s $225 for a $750 project.

Therefore, stainless steel, though pricier, may prove more cost-effective. Its durability, low maintenance, and high resale value offset the initial cost.

Mild steel, while cheap, incurs higher maintenance costs and has a lower resale value. Hence, your choice should depend on project requirements, budget, and long-term plans.

Applications

Common Applications of Stainless Steel

Industrial Use

Stainless steel boasts broad usage in industries. Its corrosion resistance is pivotal, especially in petrochemical settings. The 10.5% threshold of chromium content equips stainless steel to brave severe environments.

Notably, 304 and 316 stainless steel grades dominate, contributing 50% and 20% respectively to global production. Compared to mild steel, stainless steel’s superior resistance to oxidation, thanks to a protective oxide layer, makes it an industrial favorite.

Architectural Use

Stainless steel’s aesthetic appeal enhances architectural designs. The Empire State Building, constructed in 1930, still shines showcasing stainless steel’s durability.

Today, over 150,000 tons of stainless steel gets used annually in construction. In comparison, mild steel, lacking similar corrosion resistance, needs extra treatment for longevity, thereby increasing overall project costs.

Automotive Use

Stainless steel finds extensive use in automotive exhaust systems. Over 20% of stainless steel production goes into these components.

Grades like 409 and 439 resist heat, providing an edge over mild steel. Furthermore, stainless steel’s strength-to-weight ratio leads to fuel efficiency, an essential automotive industry factor.

Medical Use

Stainless steel’s hygienic properties suit medical applications. Surgical instruments, implants, and equipment often involve 316L stainless steel.

Approximately, 95% of hip replacements use stainless steel. Unlike mild steel, stainless steel’s non-reactive nature ensures safety in biological environments.

Kitchenware

Kitchenware is another domain where stainless steel shines. Approximately 70% of all cutleries are made from stainless steel. Its non-porous nature prevents bacteria build-up. The susceptibility of mild steel to rusting disqualifies it for culinary utensil manufacturing.

Aerospace

The aerospace industry employs stainless steel in aircraft components. Specifically, grades 321 and 347 can endure high temperatures, making them ideal.

In contrast, mild steel, with lower tensile strength, doesn’t suit high-stress aerospace applications.

Marine

The inherent capacity of stainless steel to withstand corrosion from saltwater renders it suitable for marine usage. Over 200,000 tons of stainless steel are annually used in marine construction. Unlike mild steel, stainless steel resists chloride-induced corrosion, prolonging marine structure life.

Petrochemical

Stainless steel is crucial in petrochemical plants. The preference leans towards duplex stainless steel, given its superior strength and rust resilience. Conversely, mild steel’s lower resistance to chemical corrosion makes it less applicable.

Energy Generation

Stainless steel’s heat and corrosion resistance serve energy generation industries. Around 18% of nuclear reactors employ stainless steel. The subpar thermal resilience of mild steel restricts its utility in environments characterized by elevated temperatures.

Despite the higher cost compared to mild steel, its durability, corrosion resistance, and aesthetic appeal make it a practical choice for many industries.

Common Applications of Mild Steel

Construction

Mild steel, in the construction industry, plays a vital role. Mild steel offers the requisite sturdiness for edifices. For example, builders use mild steel in constructing bridges.

Mild steel proves reliable as it can withstand heavy loads. Its flexibility adds to the safety of the construction. Even skyscrapers rely on mild steel’s durability. Their towering heights need the steadfast strength mild steel provides.

Automotive

In the automotive sector, mild steel is key. Car bodies often consist of mild steel due to their malleability. Factories can easily shape it into various parts, from car doors to chassis.

Furthermore, mild steel’s impact resistance makes it ideal for safety components like crumple zones. In 2022, mild steel accounted for 55% of an average vehicle’s weight, demonstrating its significant role.

Furniture

Mild steel also finds use in furniture production. Its flexibility allows designers to craft intricate, stylish designs. For instance, 70% of metal furniture pieces incorporate mild steel.

The material’s resilience ensures that the furniture lasts long and withstands daily use. So, next time you see a metal chair, remember that mild steel likely played a part in its creation.

Fencing and Agriculture

Farmers value mild steel for its versatility. In making fencing wires and agricultural tools, mild steel is indispensable in this sector.

An estimated 60% of farm tools are manufactured from this material, underlining its importance. Additionally, mild steel’s resistance to wear makes it ideal for the demanding environment of agriculture.

Infrastructure

Infrastructure development relies heavily on mild steel. Its strength and durability make it suitable for making roads, railway tracks, and airports.

In fact, 85% of the world’s railway tracks are made of mild steel. Its ability to withstand heavy loads and resist wear ensures the longevity of these crucial infrastructures.

Machinery

Machinery production also depends on mild steel. Its malleability allows manufacturers to form complex machine parts, contributing to around 40% of total machinery production. Its toughness ensures the machines can handle demanding tasks without breaking down.

Storage tanks

Mild steel’s durability makes it ideal for constructing storage tanks. Its resistance to cracking under pressure ensures the safety of stored substances. Around 75% of the world’s storage tanks are made from mild steel, highlighting its significant role in this sector.

Pipelines

Pipelines, too, benefit from mild steel’s properties. Its resistance to corrosive substances makes it suitable for transporting gases and liquids. Approximately 90% of the world’s pipelines are made of mild steel, proving its dominance in this field.

Appliances

Lastly, the appliance sector utilizes mild steel. From refrigerators to washing machines, mild steel is a primary component. Its heat resistance ensures the appliances can function safely, contributing to approximately 65% of the metal used in household appliances.

Thus, in every corner of your home, you’ll likely find an appliance made, at least in part, from mild steel.

Safety Concerns

Pic 3

Handling and Installation

Stainless steel, with a strength-to-weight ratio of 15-20%, boasts a solid advantage. Lighter than mild steel, transportation and installation is simpler. Yet, stainless steel poses challenges. Its hardness, reaching up to 200 Brinell, makes it resistant to cutting and shaping.

Mild steel, however, with 120-180 Brinell hardness, allows for easier manipulation. Additionally, the lower carbon content, about 0.05-0.25%, in mild steel promotes better welding than stainless steel with its higher carbon content, typically 0.08% and above.

Exposure to High Temperatures

When exposed to high temperatures, stainless steel displays superior resilience. It retains its structural integrity up to 870 degrees Celsius, making it ideal for high-heat applications.

Mild steel starts deforming around 250 degrees Celsius. Roughly 10.5% chromium in stainless steel forms a heat-induced shield, thus thwarting oxidation. Mild steel lacks this feature, and hence, can corrode easily in high-heat situations.

Health Risks

Both stainless steel and mild steel pose health risks during processing. For instance, stainless steel’s nickel content, usually 8-10.5%, can cause allergic reactions when airborne.

Mild steel, with its higher carbon content, can produce harmful fumes when welded. However, proper protective measures can minimize these risks.

It’s essential to follow industry safety guidelines while handling these materials to ensure maximum safety.

Maintenance Ideas

Stainless Steel Maintenance Tips

  • Regular Cleaning: Clean stainless steel using a soft cloth with warm water. Dirt can harm the metal surface. Regular cleaning keeps your steel looking new.
  • Proper Drying: After cleaning, dry the steel. Water left on the surface can lead to spots. Spots lessen the shine of your stainless steel.
  • Avoid Abrasives: Stainless steel is resistant to scratches. Yet, using harsh abrasives can damage the finish. Instead, use gentle cleaning agents.
  • Use of Polish: A polish can increase stainless steel’s shine. Use a polish designed for stainless steel.
  • Avoid Chlorides: Cleaning agents with chlorides harm stainless steel. Chlorides can lead to corrosion. Always check the label of your cleaning agents.
  • Rinse Thoroughly: After cleaning, rinse the steel well. Leftover cleaning agents can lead to damage.
  • Directional Cleaning: Always clean in the same direction. This helps maintain the steel’s finish.
  • Use Soft Tools: Use soft cloths or plastic scrubbing pads. Hard brushes can scratch the steel surface.

Mild Steel Maintenance Tips

  • Regular Inspections: Regularly inspect mild steel for signs of rust. Early detection helps prevent further damage.
  • Prompt Repairs: Fix any damage as soon as you spot it. Delays can lead to more serious issues.
  • Rust Protection: Apply rust protection to mild steel. This helps keep the metal in superb condition.
  • Use of Primer: A primer creates a protective layer on the steel. It shields against rust and corrosion.
  • Proper Storage: Store mild steel in a dry place. Moisture accelerates the process of rusting.
  • Regular Cleaning: Keep mild steel clean. Dirt and grime can speed up corrosion.
  • Use of Protective Coatings: Protective coatings, like paint, guard against rust. Regularly check the coating for any damage.
  • Avoid Chemical Exposure: Mild steel is sensitive to harsh chemicals. Keep it away from such substances to prevent corrosion.

Environmental Impact

Pic 4

Life Cycle Analysis of Stainless Steel

Stainless steel, a robust material, has a lifespan of around 35 years. During its life, the energy consumption for stainless steel production is 20,500 MJ per ton.

Also, the carbon footprint is significant at 1.9 tons of CO2 equivalent per ton of stainless steel. Nickel, a key ingredient, has a higher environmental impact because of the mining process.

The production of stainless steel demands a substantial amount of chromium, a material that may be hazardous if improperly managed.

The exceptional anti-corrosion characteristic of stainless steel boosts its lifespan, potentially compensating for its considerable manufacturing effects. Lastly, stainless steel’s high recyclability rate, about 90%, helps reduce its overall environmental footprint.

Life Cycle Analysis of Mild Steel

Mild steel, another popular material, has a shorter lifespan of approximately 20 years. It has lower energy consumption during production at 15,500 MJ per ton.

Additionally, its carbon footprint is 1.8 tons of CO2 equivalents per ton of mild steel, slightly lower than stainless steel.

However, mild steel’s lower resistance to corrosion necessitates frequent replacement and maintenance, contributing to higher environmental impacts over its life cycle.

Iron, the primary component of mild steel, has significant environmental impacts from mining, including soil erosion and habitat destruction. Notably, mild steel’s recyclability rate is also high, around 85%.

Recycling and Sustainability

Both stainless steel and mild steel have high recyclability rates. Recycling cuts raw material needs, curbing environmental harm from mining. Furthermore, steel recycling helps to conserve resources, as both types are predominantly made from finite materials.

For instance, a ton of recycled stainless steel can save 1,100 kg of iron ore and 630 kg of coal. Similarly, recycling a ton of mild steel saves 1,300 kg of iron ore and 740 kg of coal.

Conclusion

Stainless Steel Vs. Mild Steel has unique attributes and uses. While Stainless Steel’s corrosion resistance makes it ideal for medical and architectural applications, Mild Steel’s affordability is preferred in the construction and automotive fields.

Ultimately, the choice relies on specific needs. For more insights and procurement of quality steel, consider exploring TuolianMetal– a trusted source for all your steel needs.

One Stop Stainless Steel Supply.

Whether you need stainless steel materials for your business or fabrication projects, TuoLian is your best supplier. You can find all types, grades, and thicknesses based on your needs. Guaranteed that we provide the best quality at a reasonable cost.
Update cookies preferences
Scroll to Top